July 14th, 2020

US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit Opinions
Acadian Diagnostic Laboratories, LLC v. Quality Toxicology, LLC

Docket: 19-30320
Opinion Date: July 13, 2020
Judge: Andrew S. Oldham
Areas of Law: Civil Procedure, Contracts

After Acadian entered into two contracts with QT to perform lab testing, Acadian filed suit alleging that QT breached both agreements. The jury ultimately awarded Acadian damages for QT's breach of both agreements and both parties appealed. In regard to QT's contentions, the court held that the district court properly granted summary judgment on QT's liability for breaching the agreements and the district court did not err by excluding evidence about Acadian's business dealings. The court also held that Acadian's request for the entry of judgment of a higher damages figure is meritless. The court explained that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provide several ways for a federal litigant to seek a different damages figure than that which the jury awards, and Acadian chose exactly none of them. Therefore, by failing to file any motions in the district court, Acadian forfeited its ability to seek appellate review of the jury verdict.

Read Opinion